Employment Rights Act: How can organisations strengthen manager capability?
The Employment Rights Act 2025 is a once-in-a-generation set of measures, both complex and wide-ranging. While updating policies and processes will be essential for compliance, the Act also gives organisations an opportunity to strengthen their employment proposition and take a more deliberate approach to workplace decision-making.
A fundamental challenge for HR will be equipping managers to apply the measures fairly and confidently, supported by guidance and structures to promote fairness and accountability.
Our previous article explored what the changes could mean for individual employees. Here, we focus on HR’s role in enabling managers to implement the measures effectively.
Decisions sit with managers
Managers have always been pivotal in shaping employees’ experience of work, but the Act places even greater emphasis on their role. Every day, line managers translate policy into practice while balancing operational delivery with wellbeing, engagement, performance, and complex people issues - often without the time or support to do so well.
This challenge isn’t new. The pressure on “the squeezed middle” has long been recognised, and Marsh’s 2026 Global Talent Trends found that only 37% of employees have had a career conversation with their manager in the previous 12 months, just 38% receive regular feedback on how their performance and skills influence future career opportunities, and fewer than half (43%) say their manager helps the team focus on the work that matters most.
The Act adds new responsibilities and capabilities to the management role. Alongside delivering the all-important business results, managers will need to respond to questions about:
- How new employment rights affect new hires
- Changes to workplace policies, like sick pay and flexible working
- Trade union access, recognition and workforce representation.
- Organisation-wide initiatives introduced in response, such as equality action plans.
Managers are also navigating these changes as employees themselves. Before they can explain new policies and answer questions, they need time to understand what the changes mean for their own working lives.
This all comes at a time when many organisations have shifted to more of a self-service HR approach, with specialist support available when needed rather than embedded in daily decision-making. This puts more of the onus on managers to recognise when they need that help and seek it out, rather than relying on HR to guide them through every single decision. It signals an important shift in the relationship between HR and managers. Managers remain at the forefront of the employee experience, but are being asked to exercise more judgement themselves, including knowing when to bring in specialist expertise.
For HR, the challenge is to help managers apply the legislation with confidence. Unlike many organisational processes, people decisions are highly distributed. Every day, managers across the organisation make judgements about absence, flexibility, performance and employee support. HR simply cannot be involved in every decision. Its role, therefore, is to provide the frameworks, guidance and expertise that enable managers to exercise good judgement. Without that, similar situations may be handled differently across teams, creating unnecessary variation in employees’ experience and eroding trust over time.
Practical steps:
-
Identify the questions managers are most likely to face (for example, day one statutory sick pay or flexible working requests) and where greater guidance may be needed, for example in how and when they conduct absence management conversations
-
Clarify where managers have discretion and where a consistent organisational approach is a must
-
Review escalation routes so managers know when and how to seek additional guidance from HR
-
Treat managers as a key audience and tailor messages to their role.
Creating confidence in people decisions
Most organisations have established governance for areas including finance, risk and compliance. In this new employment landscape, there’s an opportunity to apply the same discipline to people decisions. While managers ultimately make them day-to-day, HR provides the frameworks and guidance to facilitate and moderate those decisions. This doesn’t remove manager discretion entirely, but helps ensure fair outcomes.
That might include:
- Clear processes for areas like flexible working, absence management and probation reviews
- Effective documentation of decisions and their rationale
- Opportunities to review decisions across teams
- Data that helps identify patterns and inconsistencies over time.
These can all help to provide the assurance that people decisions are being applied consistently across the organisation, regardless of where they’re made. Without them, an employee’s experience of their rights can vary between teams, even when policies appear neutral on paper.
Practical steps:
-
Evaluate whether decisions around people have sufficient oversight and governance
-
Identify where inconsistent decision-making is most likely to occur across teams or functions, and assess the associated risks
-
Strengthen documentation and record keeping to support evidence-based decision-making
-
Define appropriate KPIs/metrics and use data to monitor implementation and address emerging risks
Building decision-making capability in managers
Managers do not need to become employment law experts. But they do need the ability - and judgement - to apply organisational principles in everyday situations involving competing priorities and imperfect information. HR can support this by translating the legislation into practical guidance.
That means giving managers clarity on:
- Where discretion exists
- Where standardisation is essential
- When to seek advice or escalate issues
- The principles that should guide decisions
One of the most common mistakes organisations make during periods of change is overwhelming people with information. The most effective support is practical - scenario-based learning and role play are valuable here, as they allow managers to explore various situations before facing them in reality. Also, having opportunities to liaise with peers through forums and discussions can help reinforce key messages and create opportunities for shared learning.
More generally, there’s also a growing need to facilitate earlier intervention, particularly around absence and wellbeing. If managers are better supported themselves, they are more likely to recognise such issues in their teams early and intervene before they escalate, helping to create a more preventative and proactive culture overall.
Just as importantly, managers should be viewed as a priority audience in their own right, and be given the time and support to understand the changes before they are expected to implement them.
Practical steps:
-
Upskill managers around exercising judgement and how they reach decisions, rather than just focusing on the legislation
-
Use practical scenarios, FAQs and real-world examples to build confidence
-
Create opportunities for managers to share experiences, come together and learn from each other
-
Ensure managers have ongoing resources and tools, and know how to access them.
The role of communication
Effective communication is an important aspect of HR’s remit in supporting managers through change. Giving the context behind new policies so managers can answer questions consistently is key. A clear narrative helps explain your organisation's approach and intent and the principles underpinning the measures. Managers can then draw on that narrative when answering questions or explaining decisions.
Repetition matters too. There's a saying in marketing (the ‘rule of seven’) that people need to see or hear a message about seven times before they are likely to remember it or feel enough trust and familiarity to take action. From a consumer perspective, that might involve making a purchase, but the same principle is often true during periods of change. Leaders may be deeply familiar with a topic, but employees may be encountering it for the first time. Reinforcing key messages through multiple channels and formats, and regularly reviewing their effectiveness, helps people absorb key information. It also ensures policies are applied in an equitable way across the organisation.
Practical steps:
-
Develop a clear change narrative that explains what is changing, why it matters and what it means for different employee groups
-
Equip managers with the context, talking points and FAQs they need before asking them to talk about change
-
Reinforce key messages over time rather than relying on a single announcement
-
Sense-check whether employees comprehend what the changes mean and know where to access help and information should they want to learn more.
Moving beyond compliance
The Employment Rights Act introduces new responsibilities for employers, but it also creates an opportunity to strengthen the employment relationship. At a time of economic uncertainty and growing competition for critical skills, it challenges organisations to apply greater rigour and intentionality to how judgements around people are made and governed.
For many HR leaders, this may require - or indeed prompt - a shift in thinking. Supporting managers to make consistent decisions should be viewed as a core organisational capability rather than simply an HR process.
Alongside supporting individuals, HR is also pivotal in engaging with employees as a collective. We’ll examine this in our next article of the series, and explore the evolving employee relations landscape, including collective voice, consultation and trade union access, and what this means for your next steps.