DOL finally delivers proposed SECURE 2.0 e-disclosure rule changes
Key implications for plan administrators
Retirement plan administrators who rely on DOL’s 2002 e-disclosure safe harbor would need to take the following actions for employees who first become eligible to participate after December 31, 2025 (this article refers to these individuals as “new participants”):
- Deliver a new one-time paper notice to new participants before delivering the required benefit statement electronically instead of on paper
- Give new participants the ability to opt out of e-delivery of all required ERISA disclosures
Although the 2002 safe harbor applies to all ERISA-covered employee benefit plans, the proposal won’t affect disclosures for health and welfare plans.
Retirement plan administrators who rely on DOL’s 2020 e-disclosure safe harbor would need to:
- Deliver the required benefit statement on paper, unless participants affirmatively request e-delivery — which the plan would need to provide as an option
- Ensure that participants aren’t charged fees for any paper statements, including duplicate paper copies of statements previously furnished electronically or on paper
SECURE 2.0’s paper statement requirement
- Annually for defined contribution (DC) plans. DC plans that allow participants to direct their investments must furnish benefit statements at least quarterly. Those that don’t permit participants to direct their investments must furnish a benefit statement annually. SECURE 2.0 generally requires at least one of these statements to be provided on paper each calendar year.
- Every three years for defined benefit (DB) plans. DB plans must furnish a benefit statement to active participants with vested accrued benefits every three years. SECURE 2.0 generally requires this benefit statement to be provided on paper. However, many DB plans deliver an annual notice of statement availability in lieu of the benefit statement. The proposal doesn’t explicitly address whether SECURE 2.0’s paper statement requirement also applies to the notice of availability (i.e., whether at least one notice of availability must be provided on paper every three calendar years).
-
Exceptions to the paper statement requirementBenefit statements needn’t be provided on paper if the statement is furnished electronically under DOL’s 2002 e-delivery safe harbor or the participant has affirmatively requested electronic delivery. SECURE 2.0 directs DOL to make certain updates to its two e-disclosure regulations by December 31, 2024, in connection with these exceptions. The proposal would implement this statutory direction.
-
No effect on IRS e-disclosure rulesSECURE 2.0 doesn’t address the e-delivery rules for disclosures required under the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) — such as automatic enrollment and 401(k) safe harbor notices — which are governed by IRS’s more flexible electronic disclosure regulation. The IRS regulation allows furnishing notices required under the IRC electronically without consent if the recipient has the “effective ability to access” those electronic documents. Nothing in the proposal would change the IRS rules. Plan administrators using e-delivery that want to consolidate notices required under ERISA and the IRC need to keep in mind the differences between the DOL and IRS e-disclosure requirements.
Changes for new participants under 2002 rule
-
Changes would only apply to new participants
The proposal would implement SECURE 2.0’s direction to amend the 2002 safe harbor by adding new requirements for e-delivery of benefit statements to participants who first become eligible to participate — or beneficiaries who first become eligible for benefits — after December 31, 2025.
- One-time paper notice. Plans would have to furnish a one-time paper notice to new participants before electronically delivering the benefit statement that SECURE 2.0 otherwise requires to be furnished on paper. However, the notice wouldn’t be required before e-delivery of other ERISA disclosures to new participants, such as summary plan descriptions (SPDs), qualified default investment alternative (QDIA) notices, or the other three quarterly benefit statements in the case of participant-directed DC plans. In the preamble to the proposal, DOL explains that plans choosing to provide the required benefit statement on paper wouldn’t need to provide the one-time notice to new participants, even if these other disclosures are e-delivered to them.
- Content of notice. SECURE 2.0 specifies that the one-time paper notice must inform new participants of their right to request that “all documents” required to be disclosed under ERISA be furnished on paper. The proposal would implement this direction but doesn’t include a model notice administrators could use for participants who are wired at work. However, the safe harbor’s affirmative consent component already requires that participants receive an advance notice. Plan administrators using the safe harbor’s consent framework could satisfy the new notice requirement by delivering the existing advance notice to new participants on paper.
- Global opt-out right for wired-at-work employees. The current safe harbor doesn’t require plans to give wired-at-work employees the ability to opt out of e-disclosure, though they must be able to request paper copies of documents furnished electronically. However, in the preamble to the proposal, DOL interprets SECURE 2.0’s description of the one-time notice’s content as requiring plans to give new participants who are wired at work a “related global opt-out right” from e-delivery. (Participants covered under the safe harbor’s consent provision can already opt out by revoking their consent.) DOL doesn’t explain whether plans that provide the required benefit statement to new participants on paper — thereby avoiding having to furnish the one-time notice — would still have to give new participants the global opt-out right.
-
No changes for existing participantsThe initial paper notice and related global opt-out right wouldn’t apply to participants who became eligible on or before December 31, 2025. Administrators could continue electronically delivering all ERISA disclosures to these participants — including all benefit statements — and wouldn’t have to give those who are wired at work the ability to opt out of e-delivery.
Changes for all participants under 2020 safe harbor
DOL’s alternative 2020 e-delivery regulation allows retirement plan administrators to furnish e-disclosures through email or a “notice-and-access” framework that alerts participants when documents are posted to a website or other digital platform. Before e-delivering documents under this safe harbor, the plan administrator must provide an initial paper notice explaining the e-delivery method, including an explanation of how participants may receive paper copies of any covered document on request or opt out of e-delivery altogether.
The proposal would make a panoply of changes to the 2020 safe harbor in response to SECURE 2.0’s directives. Unlike the updates to the 2002 safe harbor — which would only affect e-delivery to new participants — the changes to the 2020 safe harbor would apply to all participants and beneficiaries regardless of their eligibility dates:
- Paper benefits statements no longer covered. The safe harbor would exclude benefits statements that are subject to SECURE 2.0’s paper delivery requirement from the list of documents that could be furnished electronically by default. Administrators who rely on the 2020 safe harbor would need to begin furnishing the required benefit statement on paper unless participants affirmatively elect e-delivery. However, administrators of participant-directed DC plans could continue to e-deliver the other three quarterly benefit statements.
- Option to request e-delivery of benefit statements. Administrators would need to give participants the option to affirmatively request e-delivery of benefit statements that would otherwise be delivered on paper. For participants who do so, administrators could electronically deliver the benefit statement using either of the safe harbor’s email or notice-and-access delivery methods.
- Additional content for paper statements. Administrators would need to include the following additional content on paper benefit statements:
- An explanation of how to request e-delivery of paper statements
- Contact information (including telephone number) for the sponsor, administrator, or other plan representative
- No fees for paper statements. The proposal would implement SECURE 2.0’s direction to prohibit plans that use the 2020 safe harbor from charging participants a fee for any paper benefit statements. The proposal would apply this prohibition to all benefit statements, including when participants request a duplicate paper copy of a benefit statement previously delivered electronically or on paper. The proposal would continue to allow plans to charge participants a fee for duplicate paper copies of other required disclosures.
-
Duplicate electronic statements already allowedSECURE 2.0 directs DOL to update the 2020 safe harbor to ensure that plans can furnish duplicate electronic copies of paper benefit statements. In the preamble, DOL explains that the proposal wouldn’t make any changes in response to this directive because “nothing in the safe harbor regulation restricts a plan’s ability to furnish a duplicate electronic statement.” However, DOL requests comments on whether, and in what circumstances, plans might deny duplicate electronic statements to individuals on account of their preference for paper benefit statements.
No access monitoring for e-disclosures
Nonenforcement policy
Request for comment
DOL requests comments on all aspects of the proposal by April 27, including the following specific items to help assess the proposal’s costs and benefits:
- The prevalence of electronic disclosure prior to SECURE 2.0
- The prevalence of use of the 2002 safe harbor vs. the 2020 safe harbor
- Whether the paper benefit statement requirement may encourage plans to switch from the 2020 safe harbor to the 2002 safe harbor for wired-at-work participants
- How often plans rely on service providers for preparing and mailing benefit statements and other required disclosures
Related resources
Non-Mercer resource
- Proposed regulations (Federal Register, February 25, 2026)
Mercer Law & Policy resources
- User’s guide to SECURE 2.0 (periodically updated)
- DOL starts tackling SECURE 2.0 reporting and disclosure updates (September 19, 2023)
- DOL finalizes electronic delivery rule for retirement plan notices (June 1, 2020)